From what I can find, Super America has the cheapest gas around, but you have to know how to work the deals. Keep reading to find out how!
Super America is accepting competitor's coupons, and doubling their value on Tuesdays (Tuesdays & Wednesdays gas seems to come down in price from the weekend too!). Here's a link to a 10 cents off coupon (expires 8/10/11), the highest value coupon that can be found online right now (Thanks, Kim!). You can also often find 5 cents off coupons in your mailers.
Well, that saves you some money, but you can still save about another 8 cents per gallon by becoming a Speedy Rewards member (just check inside your store to sign up). For each gallon of gas you fill you earn 10 points (and earn 10 points per dollar spent in the store). But to make the deal sweeter yet, buy a $100 gift card (either the "Speedy Cash & Food Merchandise Card" or the "Speedy Cash Gift Card") and earn another 2000 points. You can redeem points for gift cards, merchandise, or fuel savings (10, 25, and 50 cents off discounts on gas). Basically, each 1000 points comes out to be $1 towards a gift card (depending on which one you get).
You can check out their website for more details.
This post contains external links, please read my disclosure policy for more information.